The smaller cooking area was my only real concern. Im driving from FL to DC after thanksgiving and stopping at a dealer on the way to take a look. awesome brethren knowledge here! The second most crucial component of a pellet smoker is hopper capacity. Similar to the Pitts and Spitts, its also a US-based BBQ product manufacturing company. JavaScript is disabled. I got to be up close and personal with a Yoder YS-640 last yearthey are built like a tank. I also was looking at Pitts and Spitts but the inability to actually see one in person really affected my decision. Now lets take a look at different types of grills and their functionalities manufactured by these two companies. Traeger Pro 780 vs Ironwood 650 | Want To know Which Grill Is For You? If grilling were not so important to me, hands down Id take the Pitts. They answered every single question I had and walked me through the setup when I received it. Pitts and Spitts Maverick 1250 vs Yoder YS 640s Comparison Chart, Pitts and Spitts vs Yoder: Head to Head Comparison. Post your hints, tips, tricks & techniques, success, failures, but stay on topic and watch for that hijacking. It can easily do 8-9lb pork butts for example. Deciding between a Pitts and Spitts vs Yoder grill isnt rugged because they both provide the same value but at different pricing and with distinct capabilities. If budget is an issue, we dont recommend the Yoder one as it is high-priced and not really affordable. Otherwise, for regular household usage, a P&S pellet smoker is a great purchase, indeed. If you are considering a grill based on how long it has been in the market then you might just go with Pitts and Spitts, however, that is not all you need to pick an efficient grill. However, the USP of Yoder products lies in their exclusive craftsmanship. Congrats, fantastic looks great! P&S started with the Smoke Daddy hopper and controller. Yoder grills are built to withstand a lot of use, making them an excellent choice if you plan on smoking a lot of meat as well as cooking as well. The pits have a lifetime warranty against burnout. I've had food off my DB, a Yoder 640 and a Traeger. I hope you stick around. Location: SoCal, by way of Oklahoma & Texas. We have a rigorous product testing regimen. Pitts & Spitts has a direct grilling option and is cheaper than Yoders ($124.99 vs $189.00) Pitts an Spitts, Yoder - Pitmaster Club You guys provide one HELL of a SUPERB smoker! I haven't looked back and have no regrets. Pitts & Spitts offers a full family of products including traditional offset smokers, wood pellet grills, charcoal grills, travel grills, combination pits, fire pits and much more. You will be happy with either choice. Let's look into the temperature control of each brand separately. REC TEC actually performs better in this category than Traeger does because its grills have a temperature range of between . This grill has emerged as the best years and years after it was made, although its a bit pricey, it is quite efficient. The smoke profile and flavor are all similar which was a factor that moved me to a drum which provides a substantially different flavor profile. Has anyone here evaluated the Yoder YS640 vs Pitts and Spitts Maverick 1250 and decided to go with the Yoder? Comparing 480 to 850 and 640 to 1250 I believe P&S to be a better cooker/smoker. Yoder brands are the most suitable frequent BBQ competitions as each grill has an increment of five degrees. As these two pellet grills are of similar features and represent their respective brands, we can easily conclude that the Pitts and Spitts products offer more hopper capacity. Need to add a pellet to the arsenal. As Aaron says, if you are lookin' it ain't cookin'. Can your Maverick Pellet Grill Perform like an Offset Smoker? Meathead's AmazingRibs.com promises to never sell or distribute any info about you individually without your express permission, and we promise not to, ahem, pepper you with email or make you eat spam. I just ordered a pitts and spitts today.850 model. All that said, if you are set on Yoder vs Pitts and grilling is a huge priority, Id vote Yoder. As the entire body of these grills is made of 10-gauge heavy-duty steel, they are meant to last a lifetime. Its an appliance that has been handcrafted and built-in Texas, and its quite versatile as well. For Foodies. Definitely, yes. Click here to read our complete review. Pitts and Spitts and Yoder Smokers are two of the best American companies that manufacture different grills. As we review the P&S Maverick 1250 and Yoder YS 640s, we see that the P&S grills are a combination of stainless steel and carbon steel. It sells barbecues, trailers, backyard smoker equipment, and other items. I used my Traeger for just about everything and would like to continue that trend with my next purchase. Comparatively, the YS640 temperature ranges from 150 to 600 degrees. There has been quite a lot of comparison between Pitts and Spitts vs Yoder grill, but none seems to be hitting the surface for people. Click here to read our detailed review and the raves from people who own them. Its Competition Grade BBQ Products.. I've narrowed down my choice to either the P&S 850 or the Yoder 640. I have heard nothing but good about them. send us pictures of the first smoke! At this price point, I would think technique would be more important than the smoker itself. Are you a bit concerned about which company is best to purchase the grill between Pitts and Spitts vs. Yoder? Pitts and Spitts grills are made in Texas and happen to be the only wood pellet smoker in Texas too. . It comes packed with additional features like meat hooks, a grease drain and a convenient ash removal tray that makes clean up easier. And they are architectured with high-quality materials to last longer. My son has a newer one with the FireBoard and it is really cool. Constructed with high-quality components. We rarely recommend products we haven't tested and we never recommend products that we don't love. YS1500 vs Pitts and SPitts, I was on the phone earlier looking to order a YS1500 and the salesman on the other line mentioned that pitts and spits model is quite good and has PID controller and is fully welded, I know people have asked the question before about the PID and the general response has been. The key feature of any grill is functionality. Pitts & Spitts claims you can grill on this cooker, but like many other pellet smokers, the firepot is only 4 inches round. To view the purposes they believe they have legitimate interest for, or to object to this data processing use the vendor list link below. On the other hand, the Yoder grills are surely more heavy-duty, but they are the best for commercial use. Besides, all their products are quite easy to clean. Both these bard manufacture grills with unique design concepts. Pitts And Spitts vs Yoder Grills Comparison (2022), Pitts And Spitts vs Yoder Grill Comparison (Updated), Tips And Manual For Using Your Pitts And Spitts Grill, [How to Fix] Gas Grill Gets Too Hot On Low Setting, How To Get Crispy Chicken Skin On A Pellet Grill, How Long to Rest Pork Butt After Grilling, Can You Use Gasoline to Start A Grill? As a BBQ pit, which one will you choose from Pitts and Spitts vs Yoder? If we compare the Maverick 1250 and Yoder YS 640s, we see that the P&S smoker offers more cooking area. Pitts and Spitts grills can reach temperatures of over 600 degrees, and the pellet grates are very simple to clean. So, we can simply say that Pitts and Spitts grills provide more cooking surfaces than Yoder grills. Any last minute advice is much appreciated. But P&S have always looked goodI don't think you can go wrong with either. If you drive to the MAK place in Dallas, tell Bob i said high. I'm an older parent so when the kids get older, I imagine I'll be cooking for larger groups. When I say offset on the Pitts, I am referring to the opening not being directly over the fire like it is on the Yoder. Their charcoal and pellet grills are a great choice for both residential and commercial use. In fact, many of their smoking accessories have won some international prestigious competitions due to their incredible workmanship. Last year they had like 10 pellet grills going all different brands.I asked if they were selling all these brands now, it's a small place. The craftsmanship and durability of the product have made it stand out for years. These two grills come with almost the same features and price tag. No issues at all if you use the full bottom grate and then 3 half grates. This company is able to prioritize quality and design, as well as high-quality materials and meticulous attention to detail. Also has WAY better temperature control from everything I've read and it is fully welded, the yoder has sealerlike rtv on the seams. He asked me what I didn't like about the GMG other than being made overseas..temp fluctuations. The Yoder has the direct flame option so it can grill pretty well. Curious what peoples thoughts are on the yoder vs p&s. A pellet grill, on the other hand, is required to properly master that one-of-a-kind smokey barbecue flavor. Has anyone here evaluated the Yoder YS640 vs Pitts and Spitts Maverick 1250 and decided to go with the Yoder? While the Pitts and Spitts grill is also a great option for household uses, its also best used in commercial settings. To set you up for ultimate success, we also offer high quality wood pellets, grill grates, and a local Texas spice line. Introduce big, bold flavor to your BBQ and grilling creations thanks to the Meatheads Amazing line of pork, red meat, and poultry rubs as well as a KC-style BBQ sauce. The PBC has a rabid cult following for good reason. But ultimately I felt the MAK suited my needs best. Pitts and spitts grill is designed to take care of your smoking, braising, and grilling needs. Since 1983, the wonderfully named Pitts & Spitts has been making high-quality smokers in Houston, Texas. We extend this right to anyone, EU resident or not. ARRMA Kraton vs Talion Rc Truck: Which One Is Best? My one complaint, if it can be labeled a complaint, is that the diffuser with a door was not standard when I bought mine 3+ years ago. I see yoder had lots of paints issues but just spoke to them and they said they've improved their painting process. Professionals have utilized these two grilling gadgets and brands for years. But the Yoder one offers an additional feature such as the Adaptive Control System along with WiFi connectivity- cloud connectivity by FireBoard. The whole body of this grill is built with quality material, and its built to last as well. I was looking at Pitts and Spitts and then started hearing about the SmokeFire and got excited about that. Plus, they can sustain rough and repetitive use. Whether you feel like grilling briskets, pork butts, turkeys, or chicken, the 1070 sq. Our Privacy Promise, Terms of Service, Code of Ethics. You wont find many pellet grill/smokers that come close to it. Gotta respect that. Their grills have been increasingly popular over time. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. I've cooked on the Yoder and was gonna get it but after looking at the P&S I'm torn. I had a MAK II Star general. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Overall, this one is a reputed and reliable company to get the best Smoker as well as grills. With all the grates there is plenty of room though. On the contrary, a Yoder wood pellet grill seals the deal by offering more long-lasting construction and better temperature control. Needless to say, Pitts and Spitts Maverick 1250 is a famous mid-size model with incredible workmanship. ** Other cooking techniques are welcomed for when your cookin' in the kitchen. I have had zero issues with it, and everything that has come off of it has been amazing. Pitts and spitts vs rec tec. It is more expensive than many barbecue grills as well as Yoder smokers within the category, especially from top manufacturers like Pit Boss or even Traeger, yet it provides excellent value. Just my 2 cents :). Uses several variables and distributes heat evenly. Trophlin 3 yr. ago Pitts & Spitts has a direct grilling option and is cheaper than Yoders ($124.99 vs $189.00) Ciecocattivo2 3 yr. ago Fair enough. An example of data being processed may be a unique identifier stored in a cookie. As they are designed to withstand a lot of use, you can smoke a huge amount of meat repetitively. Wagyu Tomahawk on the Ultimate Smoker Pit. The P&S and the Yoder grill are both on the list of the top best grills to consider. So, this article may help you to make the right decision and get the best grill. According to reviews, this is regarded as a genuine ultimate smoker with easy-to-operate functions. There were pros and cons to both and I even waivered this weekend after making my decision. Please contact us for So Cal Delivery options. It gets plenty hot right at that spot, and the thick steel deflector plate and drip pan spread out the heat nicely, but superhot searing capability is still limited to a relatively small area. Are you more of a stainless steel grill user? To clear all the points more deeply, well compare several individual products from these two manufacturers. The major purpose of this firm is to design each product with the aim of being passed down and utilized year after year. GDPR requires that we be willing to delete any info we have about an EU resident if you request it. This grill is made to meet your demands for smoking, grilling as well as braising. As you already know, its a competition-grade pellet grill to offer an unfailing smoking experience both at home and beyond. They make everything from backyard smokers to portable kitchens you need a fifth-wheel to haul. So, its better to spend your hard-earned money in Yoder if you are running a restaurant. I'm interested in this thread but don't have experience with either of these cookers. All of the products below have been tested and are highly recommended. I don't care for and will not use the pellet grill for higher temp grilling. MAK is the Bently of pellet poopers. IN THAT TIME, PITTS & SPITTS HAS BEEN MIXING TEXAS TRADITION WITH NEW WORLD TECHNIQUES TO CONSISTENTLY PRODUCE THE BEST-LOOKING, BEST-COOKING SMOKERS & GRILLS. It basically consists of a carbon steel cooking chamber. Maybe that has changed. However, the design concepts are totally different from each other. If asked before Pitts and Spitts came out with their new. Pitts and Spitts was a HUGE name around Houston back in the 80's. Often, but not always, if you purchase a product after clicking a link on our site we get a finder's fee. I don't think I have ever seen a Yoder in person but I would assume they are great as well. pitts & spitts has been a legend in the bbq business for nearly 40 years. They can reach over 600 degrees of temperature. 327 74K views 5 years ago I received some questions about why I chose the Pitts and Spitts New Pellet Grill vs the Yoder YS 640. We reviewed the Pitts & Spitts Maverick 1250 pellet grill which is their most popular mid . Yoder grills provide superior performance. If you are, then this article may help you. In comparison to pellet grills, gas grills are usually less expensive, quicker, and can reach greater temperatures. Pitts And Spitts Grills are manufactured from stainless steel materials. Most people that have smoker issues with temp swing can't keep from opening the lid. The consent submitted will only be used for data processing originating from this website. Their team of craftsman build superior gear from steel plate and high-grade stainless steel. We are GDPR compliant (the stringent General Data Protection Regulations from the European Union that went into effect in 2018). Shipping Is Not Available For This Product. Although both are world-famous grill manufacturers, like all other pellet pits, they too have their own amenities and drawbacks. On the other hand, P&S products are also decent in terms of longevity. Appreciate the feedback. Their pellet grills are packed with special features that set them apart from the competition. Its among the best bargains for a smoker in the world. The same cannot be said about the Yoder group. These fees do not add to the price of purchase but they do help keep this site alive. The controlling system is the crucial distinction between Pitts and Spitts, as well as the Yoder grill. From this point of view, the Pitts and Spitts grills are a bit more advanced than the Yoder grills. Based on what I've read, I believe the P&S has more even temps and for me has a better overall feature set and would be my choice if buying. Key questions to add in are 1) pellet consumption, 2) do you want to control cook remotely (WiFi) & 3) how much do you want it to grill/sear {and of course a)$$$ & b) size}. I would see constant posts about paint issues, temp swing issues, temp not staying where you set it and it was almost daily that I would see something like that. Here we also compared these two companies and their products. These grills are also available at a reasonable price. Authorized Distributor For Pitts and Spitts Smokers and Grills. Needless to say, you are going to spend a marvelous time with your smoker regardless of your selection. Awesome, just ordered the 1250 with smoke box! Besides, their feature-loaded performances wont disappoint you. And the Yoder YS 640s is backed by a 10-years warranty on the grill body, 3 years on the control system, and 3 years on the igniter. Another great advantage of their grilling gadgets is that you can smoke, roast, sear, or BBQ according to your needs. I looked at the RT-700, the Yoder YS-640S, and the Pitts & Spitts Maverick 1250. If so, what sold you on the Yoder? Kids, docking a boat and unloading your new smoker. So, which brand is best between Pitts and Spitts vs Yoder as a grill manufacturer? SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases. The Pitts and Spitts grills come with a relatively conventional grill design. Would love to hear your thoughts on this cooker! Do a thorough inspection of the grill every week, Surfaces of the smoker can be washed down using soapy water and rinsed with clean water (Use natural detergent), Make sure the grill is completely cold before scooping out the ashes to be disposed, To control grease build-up, its recommended that you use a citrus-based cleaning solution. The best of the best IMO. That door makes cleaning the firebox a breeze and also allows you to easily sear directly over the flames. Affordability RT-590 grill is priced at around $1200, whereas it can also be bought from the official website of Rec Tec at $900 with free shipping. Some of the links on LF are affiliate links. I suggest you think through how you plan to use the pellet smoker: as a smoker, a grill, or both? The Pitts and Spitts grills come with a bit larger hopper than the Yoder grills. . This has zero impact on the price you pay but helps support the site. Considering all the pluses and minuses, we highly recommend the P&S pellet grills as the budget-conscious pick. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Pitts and Spitts offer a bunch of different products. The deal that Pitts and Spitts is currently offering makes the YS640s and a PS Maverick 1250 w/WI-FI are almost the same cost when considering options and tax (P&S doesnt collect in my state, Yoder does). Im seeing some feedback that would make it sound like these arent as versatile as I once thought. P&S is having a special at the moment where you get a cover and the 2 piece diffuser.What are your thoughts now for what these two companies produce in 2020? Comments on this forum helped me figure out that I wanted it for smoking, and I'm happy to use my Weber for grillin. We provide you the best reviews on kitchen products and kitchen faucets. Cooking Capacity I'm upgrading from my GMG Daniel Boone and starting to get analysis by paralysis! Try the Flat Top adjustable charcoal grill. Continue with Recommended Cookies. However, no matter what type of grill you need, this company manufactures different grills, including pellets, backyards, charcoal, and much more. Get a free 30-day trial here. He gave me a fairly detailed comparison and recommended the 700. Being a wi-fi-controlled grilling accessory, it lets you control the gadget remotely with your cell phone. There is only 1 pellet grill that has proven itself to sear GREAT and that is fast eddy. I had to sell mine when we went full time RV. Outside of that, Im looking for pros and cons of these and hoping to hear from current or previous owners. Great people to deal with and the product is built like the proverbial tank at 335# and adds lots of smokey goodness to whatever I cook HTH YMMV, I had a yoder 640 and it works well. What sold me on the Yoder was the ability to see it in person. When I was looking at grills the Pitts and Spitts was at the top of my list. Yoder grills are made from chrome-plated steel and powder-coated steel with a single layer lid. On the other hand, the Yoder grills are full-steel grills with more reliable construction. For more information, please see our Their product line includes offset smokers, fire pits, charcoal grills, wood pellet grills, travel grills, and much more. This and having to take grates out to pull the cap off was a big deciding factor. Though both brands offer outstanding temperature control, the Yoder is a bit ahead in this regard. But the Yoder ones are matchless in this regard. The best thing was the place I got it talking to the dealer. Best of all, the ease of use with the simplest set it and forget it operation lets even a novice pitmaster prepare the tastiest meal ever. Talking with the folks at P&S finalized my decision. But another disappointing factor of this amazing pellet pit is the retail price. Both dealers are within a couple of hours, my nearest stop light is 72 miles away so everything is hike. Yoder is actually cheaper if you compare stainless steel models. Just a little bit of elbow grease will get the job done. Fairly enough, they do justify their tagline by making competition-quality smokers and grills since 2007. This article is going to discuss everything about these two reputed grills manufacturer companies. This grill company focuses on quality over quality which explains why this is a great grill according to reviews. Both these two companies manufacture high-quality grills that ensure superior performance. So, it can say without any doubt that Yoder grills meet the best value for money. He never said anything bad about the Yoder just there were things that the P&S overcame. Pitts and Spitts vs Yoder - The BBQ BRETHREN FORUMS. Wasnt looking at the Pitts and Spitts, but the option to have direct grilling was a big reason I went with the YS640. Yoder is revered by competition cooks for well-designed, high end offset smokers and grills. The Yoder grill is built to bake, grill, sear, and smoke. Especially, their S-series products are intelligently designed with one of the best microprocessors in the industry. If you cant decide between these two grills, youll need to compare them. Finding out the comparison might help determine which you should spend your money on. Product links. Considering the expensive price tag, you might ignore them being unnecessarily high-end. Talking of the ceramic igniter, its a wonderful add-on for rapid and seamless ignition. They are also working to provide the users with something special in the grills. Yoder grill is designed for heavy use makes it an ideal option for you if you are going to be smoking lots of meat and cooking too. While reviewing the P&S Maverick 1250 and Yoder YS 640s, its evident that the P&S products are slightly ahead in terms of wider grilling surface, bigger hopper capacity, and more affordable price points. Be the first to rate this post. WD Purple vs Seagate Skyhawk: Best Surveillance Hard Drive, Seagate Ironwolf vs Barracuda: Best Storage Solution, Oklahoma Joe Longhorn vs Highland: Which One You Should Buy. I have the older style Yoder 640 and cannot say enough good things about it. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Haven't seen a Pitts and Spitts, but after using a YS640 for nearly a year, you would have a hard time, talking me into a different cooker. Pitts & Spitts Copyright 2022 | Site by Batch Creative. But here is an analysis of the special features of the Yoder charcoal grill and their popular pellet grill with stainless steel shelves. I still think the trap door assembly on the Yoder for direct flame sear is a better design than the P&S which requires you to move the shield to access the flame after you remove the trap door.