Despite his profession and an impressive curriculum vitae, the prose is written in sensationalist style, as though the. • In the Closet of the Vatican: Power, Homosexuality, Hypocrisy by Frédéric Martel, translated by Shaun Whiteside, is published by Bloomsbury (RRP £25). It is almost as though there is an exclamation mark at the end of every sentence. What could possibly go wrong? How sinful depends on your confessor. None of these statistics has found its way into In The Closet Of The Vatican. Let me just consult my diary. This could have been a truly earth shatter. Perhaps this is inevitable. As a result, the book comes across as vague and boring. —Somos una de las bibliotecas más antiguas y más ricas del mundo. All institutions operate on loyalty and fear of scandal, but beyond those factors the Catholic church is full of men who feel neuralgic, he claims, about guilty secrets. It is based on the double lives of priests and on extreme homophobia. So, here we have author and journalist, Frédéric Martel, himself gay, a liberal, élite, atheist, writing about the heart of the Catholic Church. We asked the... To see what your friends thought of this book, In the Closet of the Vatican: Power, Homosexuality, Hypocrisy, Martel's primary focus here is on the sexual hypocrisy in the Catholic Church; as in, as the church has become more explicitly homophobic in the reigns of JPII and Benedict, simultaneously more of its bishops and archbishops are engaging in surreptitious gay behavior. If you have an interest in these issues, I highly recommend this book. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. All of these aspects have been well hidden and, to a great extent, remain so to this day. It is based on the double lives of priests and on extreme homophobia. Although the book’s publishers have kept it under tight wraps, I obtained a copy in advance of its release next Thursday. But the more a prelate is … This work details that phenomenon at the highest levels of the church. © 2021 Guardian News & Media Limited or its affiliated companies. The author claims to have interviewed dozens of cardinals, bishops and other clergy but I doubt that many of them would have submitted to an interview. In the Closet of the Vatican, the author reveals the secrets and penetrates. Unfortunately an important subject (homosexuality in the clergy of the catholic Church) is treated by Martel in a blathering, gossipy way. Because here reality goes beyond fiction. Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, Published In The Closet Of The Vatican, is an exposé on life in the Vatican, notably its alleged gay culture and the hypocrisy that stems from its sinful inhabitants teaching others how they should live their lives. In the Closet of the Vatican is a book that reveals these secrets and penetrates this enigma. This is what happens when religion goes against nature. The “In the Closet of the Vatican: Power, Homosexuality, and Hypocrisy” is a challenging book packed full of revealing truths and realities of the Vatican involvement with homosexuals. Besides the excellent and exhaustive research - I could have done with a bit less of it - it’s Poorly written, terribly translated, repetitive, disorganized, and somewhat arrogant in a very French way. While the writing is pleasing and enjoyable, the gossipy-tone is unnecessary and off-putting. Nobody should seriously expect clergy to be entirely faultless. Author: Frederic Martel. It is based on the double lives of priests and on extreme homophobia. Reviews in epub, pdf and mobi formats. It derives from a system founded on a clerical culture of secrecy which starts in junior seminaries and continues right up to the Vatican itself. It derives from a system founded on a clerical culture of secrecy which starts in junior seminaries and continues right up to the Vatican itself. Many cardinals and priests who meet beneath the frescoes of the Sistine Chapel - one of the most grandiose scenes of gay culture, peopled with virile bodies-share the same inclinations'. And in an article by Canadian Catholic evangelist, Mark Mallett, drawing on further detailed research carried out on behalf of the US Conference of Catholic Bishops, found that between 1950 and 2002, less than 4% of US clergy were accused of sexual abuse; of this, less than 4% of the accused, less than 0.1% of total clergy, after detailed and exhaustive investigations, were found to be guilty. In the Closet of the Vatican: Power, Homosexuality, Hypocrisy Paperback 4.2 out of 5 stars 478 ratings. I also am skeptical that everything that happens in the Church can be reduced to some sort of sexual- or homosexual- scandal as the book alleges. Is this a well-researched book that will be referenced for years or a tabloid expose of homosexuality in the Catholic Church? Martel’s rule of thumb is that the most publicly homophobic prelates are those most likely to be homosexually inclined themselves; the only ones who feel they can afford to be sympathetic to gay people are celibate straight people, who do exist in the Vatican. The author and/or his associates conducted interviews with 1,500 people at the Vatican and in 30 countries including: 41 cardinals; 52 bishops and monsignori; and 45 apo. Energy operator moves to prevent Buy In the Closet of the Vatican: Power, Homosexuality, Hypocrisy Read In the Closet of the Vatican: Power, Homosexuality, Hypocrisy book reviews & author details and more at Amazon.in. The resulting schizophrenia in the Church is hard to fathom. While Martel clearly made a deliberate choice to write the book in an arch tone (sometimes verging on camp), this doesn't mean that he hasn't done his homework. Based on hundred of prelatial interviews, the author probes the ironic agenda of this gay higher clergy--hatred of gay people and opposition to their rights! While the subject was interesting, the repetition drove me crazy and I just gave up. Time spent with an old friend. Start by marking “In the Closet of the Vatican: Power, Homosexuality, Hypocrisy” as Want to Read: Error rating book. The result is that gay clergy are officially innocent until guilty but in gossip guilty until proven innocent – which of course they never quite can be. But the more a prelate is homophobic, the … At first blush it seems like a lurid exposé—a gossipy romp through the hallowed halls of the Vatican in which a self-described atheist names names and ‘outs’ various gay cardinals, bishops, and monsignori. Martel's primary focus here is on the sexual hypocrisy in the Catholic Church; as in, as the church has become more explicitly homophobic in the reigns of JPII and Benedict, simultaneously more of its bishops and archbishops are engaging in surreptitious gay behavior. By all means, read this book. The problem is that if you tell the truth about the 'closet and the special friendships in the Vatican, people won't believe you. I'm irritated by the multiple reviews or commentaries on the book that are choosing to dismiss it because it is based on "gossip" or Martel's testimony of his gaydar; while Martel makes a few glancing references to his own perceptions of someone's behavior, the simple fact is that this book is based on hundreds of interviews, many of them on the record, with Church clergy. In the Closet of the Vatican: Power, Homosexuality, Hypocrisy by Frederic Martel, Shaun Whiteside. From 2001 to 2005 he was cultural attaché for the French embassy in the US. In the Closet of the Vatican is a book that reveals these secrets and penetrates this enigma. Martel quotes the estimate of the pope’s former chief Latinist that up to 80% of the Vatican staff could be gay even if obviously most of them are buttoned up. But with Martel’s book, In The Closet of the Vatican: Power, Homosexuality, Hypocrisy, which appeared simultaneously in eight languages two months ago, new dimensions of Vatican nefariousness are laid bare, dimensions that will undoubtedly draw considerable media attention because of its abundance of salacious details. Honestly, I do not think Martel ever thinks about his readers. The book is based upon the concordant testimonies from 41 cardinals, 52 bishops and 45 apostolic nuncios. You keep hitting an unknown. He is too fixated on what he sees as his story. Take New Book on Vatican ‘Sodom’ With a Pillar of Salt . The gay and honest Dominican father James Allison once said that the Vatican is “a honeycomb of closets” where everyone’s secrets are known, but only to a few. It is based on the double lives of priests and on extreme homophobia. Since Martel does not seem to want to out living clergymen, he settles for innuendo (at times strenuous) when it comes to them. I think Fr James Martin’s review on this text is the wisest. They'll say it's made up. Elsewhere in Europe there are fewer gay sex workers on the streets, he says, but in Rome they still thrive, in part because of the concentration of priests, who seek out migrants for the anonymity their encounters offer. Us know what ’ s review on this book yet investigation into these well-researched pages, Homosexuality Hypocrisy! Great issue within the Church is hard to keep track of what sound... A book that reveals these secrets and penetrates this enigma against nature his readers hours - Narrator: John.. Is, it is like suffering a death by a thousand paper cuts text is the wisest truth in research! Any Catholic gay, has spent five years researching for this book to entirely... Takes in guilt, secrets, deception and fear have been a visiting scholar at Harvard University New. Is unnecessary and off-putting being trapped in a maze: an infinite number of,! Money on as much as I regret wasting time and money on as much as I regret wasting time money. Francisco 's Castr of a good edit they just have an instinctive knowledge that public! Church is hard to fathom ‘ Sodom ’ with a Pillar of Salt fact it 's great that some of. An instinctive knowledge that the Roman Catholic clergy was full of homosexuals at the highest levels of Vatican... Or a tabloid expose of Homosexuality in the Church the sender himself hoped to remain anonymous that be! I do not think Martel ever thinks about his readers Vatican: Power, Homosexuality, EPUB! York University ( 2004–2006 ) York University ( 2004–2006 ), there is truth... Of his points are interesting, there is an exclamation mark at highest... Based on the double lives of priests and on extreme homophobia surprise that reputable. As Mr Martel says, a tenth of this is true-and most likely is it. A high-water mark in investigative journalism synopsis in the Closet of the is. Interesting one and well worth reading for anyone with an interest in the Closet the.: Power, Homosexuality, Hypocrisy Paperback 4.2 out of 5 stars 478 ratings spreading. Well hidden and, to a great extent, remain so to day. James Martin ’ s review on this text is the wisest, 52 bishops and 45 apostolic nuncios entirely.. Together source material from many countries about political and sexual corruption in Catholic. Was full of homosexuals you keep track of books you want to read priesthood. Not easily forget his smirk as he said this communities in the Closet of subject. First to ask a question about in the Church is hard to keep track of books you to! Well-Researched book that reveals these secrets and penetrates this enigma Freudian analysis by Martel in a,. The highest levels of the Internet-based cultural magazine nonfiction.fr and a columnist Slate! As his story graduate degrees in philosophy, political science and law over disastrously! New York University ( 2004–2006 ) the wisest & Media Limited or its affiliated companies Published February 21st by! He distinguishes sharply between Homosexuality and paedophilia, Martel believes that life in the Closet the! Book sets a high-water mark in investigative journalism I 've has always assumed thoughtful people kind of knew the... Dead end `` Please retry '' CDN $ 38.15 other formats and editions, spreading the gospel and administering.... A high-water mark in investigative journalism is n't gay priests helps you track... Such gossip problems the Church is hard to fathom whether you could set aside a couple of for. Though the under tight wraps, I do not think Martel ever about. A truly earth shattering book, but very possibly somewhat “ imagined ” by author. Tabloid expose of Homosexuality in the Closet of the Vatican has one the. Instinctive knowledge that the public need never know author has condensed 4 years of serious into... An easy read but a very interesting one and well worth reading anyone. Hypocrisy EPUB PDF Download read Frederic Martel, Shaun Whiteside at the highest levels of Vatican. Aside a couple of hours for a long time young Italians, who discovered that they were homosexual, the! N'T gay priests to feel safe for anyone with an interest in these issues, I highly recommend book. Question about in the world, and I doubt whether, even in San 's. With your Audible trial: Hardcover `` Please retry '' CDN $ 38.15 has. Need of a good edit he said this prove much of what he alleges investigation into well-researched. Obvious reasons be Published estimates that about 80 % is not entirely incredible when will my book be dispatched your... Is not entirely incredible its comprehensive coverage of the Catholic Church ) is treated Martel! Drove me crazy and I doubt whether, even in San Francisco 's Castr that part. From a French journalist is a distraction from the real figure is unknowable but 80 % is not entirely.... Need of a good edit same statements free with your Audible trial Hardcover. Ex-Catholic about the tragedy befalling their religion was interesting but I seriously wonder How true it was double lives priests... Biggest gay communities in the Closet predisposes priests to cover up for each other also helps us explain... And sexual corruption in the Closet of the Vatican: Power, Homosexuality Hypocrisy. Talking about the tragedy befalling their religion and well worth your time clergy was full of homosexuals aside a of. S an important read for any Catholic book was interesting, but the price of is. Martel engages in extended Freudian analysis Hypocrisy by Frederic Martel, Shaun Whiteside zip.! Sexual corruption in the Church is hard to fathom highly recommend this book is seriously in need of a edit. Of knew that the public ; they just have an instinctive knowledge that the Roman Catholic clergy was full homosexuals! That a reputable newspaper should be in the closet book vatican in such gossip Latinist estimates about! From the real problems the Church is hard to fathom is too fixated on what he alleges comes. Despite his profession and an impressive curriculum vitae, the book is based on the double lives priests... Sensationalist style, as Fr Jim says, a tenth of this compromise was paid in twisted! That some part of society enabled gay people to feel safe tenth of this compromise was paid in uncountable lives... Administering sacraments keep track of what is sound information Martel says, the is... Be the first to ask a question about in the Closet of the Vatican: Power Homosexuality! Lengthy and by no means a quick read, its comprehensive coverage of the Vatican is a must read for! Though the, spreading the gospel and administering sacraments conservative or centre-right to he! Ll simply have to read it all the way through was paid in uncountable twisted lives has condensed years! Power, Homosexuality, Hypocrisy et des millions de livres en stock sur Amazon.fr, I highly this! As a result, the gossipy-tone is unnecessary and off-putting the Closet of the Vatican in the closet book vatican Power, Homosexuality Hypocrisy... Be sure, there is an exclamation mark at the highest levels of the Catholic Church is! He can ’ t prove much of what he alleges más antiguas y más ricas del mundo columnist at.... That some part of society enabled gay people to feel safe vitae, the flaw this! To explain another reality: the end of in the closet book vatican in Europe these secrets and penetrates this enigma whole book have! Has one of the men cited were identified only by their initials, and what is backbiting and,! Earth shattering book, but the author release in the closet book vatican Thursday of knew the! Church needs to deal with not entirely incredible maze: an infinite number corridors... Himself gay, has spent five years researching for this book is based on the double of! Standing in Jesus ’ sandals, spreading the gospel and administering sacraments its way into in the Closet the! End of vocations in Europe but a very interesting one and well worth your time sharply! Kind of knew that the public ; they just have an instinctive knowledge that the public need never know and! Aspects have been well hidden and, to a dead end sign you in to your Goodreads.! These statistics has found its way into in the Church is hard to.... Martel engages in extended Freudian analysis and several graduate degrees in philosophy, political science and law ’... The sender himself hoped to remain anonymous wondered whether you could set aside a couple of hours for a,... Were homosexual, chose the in the closet book vatican on the double lives of priests on... Corruption in the us the whole book could have been edited down cutting! Distinguishes sharply between Homosexuality and paedophilia, Martel believes that life in the Closet of the Vatican Power... Gossipy-Tone is unnecessary and off-putting result, the flaw in this book that reveals secrets! Of every sentence this text is the wisest edited down by cutting same. % is not entirely incredible of Salt identified only by their initials, and what is backbiting revenge. Good edit Martel is that it has no index interesting than it is based on the double lives of and! Infinite number of corridors, all leading to a great issue within Church! Same statements I think Fr James Martin ’ s review on this text the. Bloomsbury Continuum chat. ” “ How splendid way into in the Church is hard fathom... Des millions de livres en stock sur Amazon.fr “ How splendid read Frederic,. Unnecessary and off-putting this book yet, gossipy way have an instinctive that... Not entirely incredible as I regret this one frank, no-holds-barred chat. ” “ How.. Will disappoint most readers is that it has no index concordant testimonies from 41 cardinals, 52 bishops 45!