OMGAI thanks so much for recapping this, HeadsNo2 n.n I've literally been coming back to Dramabeans every other hour to see if the recap has been posted yet lol (and all my other hours, I've been watching and re-watching, then rewinding and re-rewatching the same 1 scene from episode 8 of "You're the Best, Lee Soon-shin") haha n.n, It seems to me that the writer changes her mind many times regarding many aspects as she wrote the drama. (I could buy him being dead if they'd left it at the bicycle scene -- but the restaurant was too real.). I don't blame people for being suspicious though. Ah, so maybe shes making plans for the future since she wants to have a future now. However, she seems to be lost in a hallucination of her earlier days, when her husband refused to believe her about the presence of an ominous entity. Find more reviews and book recommendations on my blog. Soo falls to the ground with his hand holding his bleeding gut. Seriously I kept fast forwarding cuz there was nothing intriguing. One day, Anne is walking by the lough when she hears a familiar whistle, and Thomas arrives. *sighs* I need the (halmeoni) from Goodbye Solo to comfort me right now, so disappointed am I in the finale and in the drama as a whole. She gave the story a nostalgic feel I reveled in.Thank you, Amy Harmon, for the chance to read an ARC and for kicking my reading year off with a bang. For me, it's because I only read the recap, and I really thought Young was only imagining it. Young is not a character I will pretend to understand through and through, lol. DUDE. I just enjoy the cinematography. Well, Young must be alive. Finally, as to Wang coming backtruly platonic relationship. This is exactly what I said. But I guess in the end, what's important is that they both reconciled and expressed their love to each other and whether they really lived or died didn't matter to me. , Page numbers source ISBN He is forever amazing there! I glossed over a lot of the things a lot of people struggled with eg. I'm glad that this was my first. Amy Harmon is a New York Times, Wall Street Journal, and USA Today bestselling author of thirteen novels, including From Sand and Ash, and the Whitney Awardwinning The Law of Moses. Reviewed in the United Kingdom on February 23, 2019. (And we don't know because we don't see anything alluding to that). Some of my questions might seem superficial, however I wish things had been made clear for us :-(. Like you, I didn't understand why she couldn't have that conversation with OS when she was having her tea and he was there (right there), and she had already shared her questions with him. And with that, all the players get gambling, while Young spends a restless night at the hospital window with the winter wind blowing. Love is love, no matter which year we live in. I had watched NG but do not remember how the drama ended but I will remember every details about TWTWB. Wind Poem Summary. She got the call from Jin-sung while she was on her way to treat Young. As she tries to free herself from the bed, Isaac attempts to stop her and gets stabbed in the process. This is going to be in my all time fav list. I'm with you-- this would have been a wonderful drama if the writers hadn't given up on the characters towards the end: I felt that we were just coasting, or worse, slipping and sliding, as the show labored its way into the finale, and there wasn't even a good "save" in the closing moments. 'Into The Wind' Ending, Explained: Did Michal Survive The Accident? help you understand the book. As folks already pointed out, I just don't get why Sec. Its interesting to note that, apart from possibly being tricked by the evil entity to murder both Emma and Isaac, Lizzy also had real-life motives to cause them harm. I was waiting to see if the aftermath changed how I felt about the whole ordeal, since there was a chance for the show to treat the attempt in a thoughtful and meaningful way. ASIN Now, I just can't watch JIS without thinking "he did a porn movie" Cause that's what it is. Unable to add item to List. appId : '127538621120543', Oh you have made it perfect sense.I did not feel the flowers were for the grave, as lambs ear was more for OY than OS. I think they were talking about actually bringing flowers for his restaurant. Neither of them died! So, the suicidal attitude has always been there and it takes months of treatment, so I can totally relate to OY each time she is going back and forth with the suicidal attempt or negativity towards life. Then the shape of a man starts to form. But to me what he did made sense for the character. I'm not a Kim Bum fan anyway, so when he's still acting adolescent in the tractor scene I just wanted to smack him upside the head. What the wind knows ending explained. I could feel the discomfort of the clothing, the confusion of being in a new place and time, and see the world as if I was reading in 3D. South Wind Knows My Mood Episode 40. Hence, left all alone and surrounded by the vast open prairie, Lizzy begins cleaning up her blood-soaked kitchen. Despite the fact that she threw the keys blindly into the greenhouse shrubbery the night before, Young emerges into the secret room without a speck of dirt on her. I can see just enough to see that youre very good looking, she adds. Jin-sung arrives in the meantime so Boss Man can declare him Soos gambling partner, and all of Soos huffing and puffing cant reverse the situation now. I didn't think about it that way when watching the final scene so i believed they both died. Please enter your username or email address. Soo calls Mi-ra to say hes on his way, but still, shouldnt he stay to make sure Jin-sung gets out of there? 5 min read. The flowers of MS and JS was at the table. The ending of The Thing is a hotly debated subject amongst nerds and fans everywhere. As Anne fell for Thomas, I did too. And with just an "I'm sorry". The ending just seemed so fanservice (and I know I have already said that, however, that feeling kept staying with me). When I started watching I already accepted the fact that someone or even all of the lead characters might die. Because a dead Soo wont give him any money, Boss Man has no choice but to try and win the pot to save himself from bankruptcy. I also like how she explains things, we get to see her thought process and I am grateful for that. We are then transported to Emmas burial, where she is briefly seen with a massive head injury, most likely from a gun. For taking the time to actually write it out or type it out in this case. Too many very explicit sex scenes without enough justification. If it'd been left with Soo on a bicycle, then I'd have leaned towards him being dead. She knew little of her familys history, and Ireland has such a complex, turbulent past. He is the same person Vusi takes a bribe from at the film's beginning. BOO-mother-frikkin-HOO. Something about it resonated, and while fiction hasn't been so good for me lately, I had a feeling about this one and I was right. This happy ending is actually way too perfect to be realistic, and these characters definitely lucked out to be able to survive in a melodrama. So much attention has been put into every character's emotions, and perhaps it was that which made the last couple of episodes lacking in spunk. 1. All three were markers of humanity, of time, of life. At least Moo-chuls minion seems to have Jin-sungs back. In fact, it is the arrival of her husband that stops her from committing suicide. The hunter knows without a shadow of a doubt that Cas was telling the truth because the Empty wouldn't have claimed him in a moment of true happiness if he weren't. Soo drags his feet, futilely trying to make it to the hospital as blood streams from his wound and tears stream from his face. If the stories are gone, then the people are gone too. Print Word PDF This section contains 688 words (approx. Ill miss it so much :D. I wanted to clear some things up for you, because I also had my doubts about whether Soo died or not at first. More importantly, Young, you are being kissed by Soo! But in true drama fashion, we know Soos cards must be the winning ones, and Jin-sung knows as well since Soo just leaves him there. He lived like a dog, and died like a dog, she laments, though shes not willing to let Soo comfort her as she tells him that he wont be needed at Moo-chuls cremation. They shift into her perspective when she was in the cab and saw the cherry blossoms, that's when the scene actually changed. The beginning of this drama was so so so good!!! Show! @ jenn, you're right. Since everyone went all in, he won the game, and all of Boss Mans money. I was so involved in it I just could not put it down. I'm in dramaland and i want the happy ending of course. Granted, I'm not familiar with Irish history, making everything in these pages new to me. I highly recommend reading this book I cried like a baby. The ending was definitely real. Lake Union Publishing, Seattle, WA, 2019. What the Wind Knows by Amy Harmon - Goodreads It's even weirder cuz 2 eps ago lawyer ahjussi was angrily throwing her out asking her if she's human and all and then hey! The blurry images say no. On one hand, there are a number of physical manifestations of this alleged demon. It's at a drama's standpoint. Still, I'm glad that none of the main characters died. This article contains Eternals spoilers.. Eternals is a big movie for Marvelin every sense of the word.. But Golden Wind was never meant to be about the best of society either. i don't think dreaming would be like that. An Amazon Charts, Wall Street Journal, and Washington Post bestseller. But no, Young frequently visited Soo's cafe, hears the bell on his bracelet and yet Soo doesn't reveal to her that it's him until much later. She is then seen shooting Emma. Also, when OY did that (push back when she would ask questions to OS), it reminded me some of Faith, when CY told the doctor that he would ask her later to stay with him and get her answer then. Gideon is timid and ineffectual, while Emma soon begins to claim that she is being haunted by some kind of unseen entity that inhabits the scrubland that stretches out all around them. Or they could be alive and the memorial was for brother Soo. All suicide attempts are a cry for attention? Were Boss Man's minions watching to make sure OS had been killed? There never is a straight ending in Kdramaland. so that ending was weird, to say the least. Did the CCTV goons end up getting him because his promise, in a sense, broke (to let Soo & Jin Sung go unscathed)? In that case then, why stab him in the first place? Lizzy (Caitlin Gerard) and Isaac Macklin (Ashley Zukerman) live in isolation on a tract of land in New Mexico in the 1800s. Skillfully woven around vividly depictedhistorical events and figures, this is a page-turner, hard to put down until the end. Helen Bryan, international bestselling author of War Brides, The Sisterhood, and The Valley, An inspiring exploration of a setting seldom found in historical fiction, What the Wind Knows is a heartfelt, beautifully written journey through time, history, and love. fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs); If that had been me, I'd have taken the knife and gone after Kim. Caught between history and her heart, she must decide whether shes willing to let go of the life she knew for a love she never thought shed find. (There were some recaps that got things factually wrong and so of course they didn't make sense.). Well done. and the kiss at the beginning is (for me) the best kiss of this year in dramaland! What the Wind Knows - amazon.com What If? season finale recap: Ending, post-credits scene explained for It made me wonder if because this was a melodrama, the writer had the characters inflict (more) pain to each other for the sake of the nature of the drama fitting the bill (of a melodrama) till the end. It is interesting to note that the only person that we see interacting with the reverend is Lizzy. The whole premise of this drama was about a woman who wanted to die and a man who wanted to live, so im guessing this outcome makes sense. I've caught myself saying, "WHAT??? With TWtWB's both leads had their stories wrapped up fairly well and the story-fail was in a secondary line that, in the end, didn't actually affect much. Her suspicions are confirmed when she finds Emma's diary in her cabin, which details not only her secret relationship with Isaac but also the fact that the baby Emma was carrying may have been his and not her husband's. this reminds me why I'm not a fan of the genre. The flowers were present at the cafe table where Young was seated too. Jin-sung spots him while on his way to the hospital and starts to piggyback him the rest of the way, even though Moo-chuls already got one foot in the other world as he mumbles, Just leave me be, Jin-sung doesnt give up, until he feels Moo-chul go limp on his back. i had the same reaction when a friend told me, man! This study guide contains the following sections: This detailed literature summary also contains Quotes and a Free Quiz on what the wind knows ending explained You will answer all my questions honestly. How about NOW, since youre already asking the questions? Sex is a natural part of our life and that is artistically shot and they are just depicting a natural human behavior to get aroused and be lustful, because if you don't then you are not normal . Brief content visible, double tap to read full content. I concluded. Her joy now was in helping others with similar disabilities and experiencing her love for Soo in her mind. They didn't treat it as a "melodrama disease" with over exaggerated helplessness or what have you. I guess there are so many probabilities with this, it's kind of crazy. Reviewed in the United States on February 21, 2023. With his eyes darkening ominously, he then chases Lizzy out of her house. JS to me was a consistent character. To me it looks like the last 3 episodes were written by a different person. Same here. They eventually decide on lambs ear, because that was the plant special to him and Young. Good to know a little wrist-slitting never hurt anybody. But, as much as I hate to say it, having seen dramas of hers like Goodbye Solo or More Beautiful Than a Flower, I can't help but feel that she's sold a part of her soul to write TWTWB (which was far more commercially successful). I absolutely love your comments and totally agree word for word with your analysis. But they crammed it into like a freaking two-minutes-reactionif that. "But the wind and water know all the earth's secrets. Wow. I think the whole flower thing is to amend for stabbing Oh Soo. In an unforgettable love story, a woman's impossible journey through the ages could change everything Anne Gallagher grew up enchanted by her grandfather's stories of Ireland. but the 'open' ending is so well done, that whenever, however I feel, I could say, ok, Soo is dead or ok, this is a happy ending. Wow, now that "winter" has past, I can finally breathe. They talked about making Jin-sung betray his friend, but the way they chose to do it didn't make any sense whatsoever. Only when hes out does he call Secretary Wang to ask her to return, because hell feel more at ease if shes there to take care of Young. Lizzy's tale is pieced together through time jumps, simultaneously exploring her sinister past and rapidly deteriorating present. The physical dangers were numerous, but in the 2018 horror film "The Wind" ( which was added to Netflix in June ), it's the psychological terrors that take focus. Even then it wouldnt matter, since Boss Man wanted him dead, but why? Just read and look where Song was interviewed, she also concluded TWTWB was a happy ending story. 'The Wind' is a slow-burn horror-mystery based in the Wild West. Now that was a great ending. I see that as a sign that they are now in heaven-finally away from all the pain and suffering that tormented both while they were alive. '1923' Ending Explained: 5 Ways Season Finale Brought Closure | IndieWire The title is "Gu Family Book" which is why I expected there's some kind of journey to find said book or even the appearance of it. The surreal film follows a womans slow descent into madness as she struggles to survive the crushing solitude of the 19th-century frontier lands. Perhaps instead of questioning whether Lizzy's experiences were real or imagined, the film is trying to suggest that both things can be true at once. NHK stay true to the japanese drama, so the stabbing scene is actually in the jdrma version too, so I don't think they just copied nice guy, maybe it's the other way around. It's what sets this drama apart from the movie version which was a neat package in itself but i felt the drama extended and explored and fleshed out the characters on a deeper level that made me - with the exception of Sec Wang (whatthehell show- she made her blind, i don't care how well she can cook)- connect with the narration as a whole. And with that, all the players get gambling, while Young spends a restless night at the hospital window with the winter wind blowing. 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. All rights reserved. Order our What the Wind Knows Study Guide. She would have been very selfish and unchanging because she wouldn't know who could be trusted, especially when you know your step mom has sabotaged your eyes. It took some time for me to grasp the numerous characters and the history taking place. I guess I cant begrudge a character for not being selfless, so Ill boil it down simply: No matter her deep-seated issues, Young didnt make for an enjoyable heroine. Her fantasy novel, THE BIRD AND THE SWORD was a Goodreads Best Book finalist. Because now just isnt a good time? Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required. I Think the drama ended in happy ending. I salute the writer as well as Ju in sung and Oh young very well-acted characters. When she was with Secretary Wang, Lawyer Jang, and her ex-fiance with those blind kids, those scenes were not blurry. That is, until another couple, Emma (Julia Goldani Telles) and Gideon Harper (Dylan McTee), move into a cabin nearby. Lawyer Jang tries to get Soo to take the money on Youngs behalf, since it would make her feel better. What's Up With the Ending? She finds the headstone for her great-grandmother, Eoin's mother, who was also named Anne Gallagher. She takes Soos face in her hands as she adds that she has more to tell him, but itll wait until after her surgery. Whilst I have read several books from this period, this one was special. Unlike some people, I absolutely loved the happy ending. "What the Wind Knows" is less sex heavy, more passionate romance wise, and the plot line is more intense. She also manages to locate the chlorine gas the CRM was hiding at the culling station . And the good times keep going as Soo helps Jin-sung and his family pack for their move to the countryside. Sigh. my two cents anyway. The following version of the book was used to create this study guide: Harmon, Amy, What the Wind Knows. I have just finished this beautiful book and have read it continuously for the last couple of days or so. The film begins in the aftermath of her death and one of the earliest lines of dialogue sees Lizzy saying to Isaac, "She had my gun How did she get my gun?" What we dont know is whether Lizzy was in her senses when she committed the murder. I think part of the problem lies with how the show quickly glossed over Jin Sung's dilemma and there were also no explanations on how Soo all of a sudden is alive in the end. And the wind finally stopped blowing! I don't see how the ending could be just a dream. Eoin is a retired doctor who grew up in Ireland, and Anne is a successful author. He turns back to her with a smile, and rings the bell bracelet. I don't count it as a story fail because it's well supported (Wang was always shown to love and support Young) but it's so weird! There were a lot of "wth" moments in the last few episodes that were left unresolved. I totally agree with all your comments, except, I rather liked how they twisted the Jin Sung - Oh Soo loyalty in the end. They seemed to have resorted back to their just friends status although Sung was still very much in love with her still. What the Wind Knows grants a shift in perspective, allowing readers to realize what is important has always been important. These last few episodes were off and did not match up to the earlier episodes. Turns out Moo-chul wasnt stabbed, because hes too legit to quit. D: I checked my brain at the door before watching this episode and was perfectly happy with the ending. He was timeless - simple, yet strong, and completely human. Maybe they are all waiting for Moo chul to show up. everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of What the Wind Knows. The poet says that the wind makes a mockery of . I was not disappointed in the least and I cannot say how grateful I am that I was able to escape my own reality for a few hours. No, I actually think it is genuinely impressive. I dont understand why this conversation cant happen now. Soo holds Jin-sungs face for as long as he can, and the two stare wordlessly at each other until Soo cant hold himself up any longer.