Dementia can be one of the side effects of metal poisoning. Fresh warning over toxic metal hip replacements... now doctors claim they could cause Alzheimer's There are concerns that the devices are leaching toxic chemicals into … It’s called an FDG-PET brain scan—and if you have ACE, it will light up like a Christmas tree. Cobalt Toxicity. Both the socket and the ball are made of stainless steel, titanium, chromium, cobalt or some combination of these. Metal on metal hip replacements can release high levels of metal particles like cobalt and chromium into a patient’s body.  This happens when the metal surfaces of the cup and ball rub together and flake off tiny metal ions that travel through the body in the bloodstream causing metal poisoning.  Dementia can be one of the side effects of metal poisoning. Your Healthy Pet - Furry kids need to be well fed too! Cobalt poisoning can also occur from the wear and tear of some cobalt/chromium metal-on-metal hip implants. Within weeks, her skin broke out in boils. August 1, 2017, 1:30PM. It’s okay. He believed the cobalt poisoning from the hip implant caused sudden decline in psychological health. In most cases, a failing hip replacement needs to be surgically replaced. I feel that your efforts on my part made all the difference. And if you’re contemplating this kind of procedure, your surgeon should have a recommendation. About 1 in 7 show declines across all brain networks. Cobalt, titanium and other metals in hip replacements can cause metallosis, or metal poisoning. I just wanted to thank you for your Thank goodness I found you and your law firm. You have held my hand through a lot and each and everyone of you at MCT are appreciated for all of your efforts. Three different case studies of cobalt toxicity after hip replacement surgery were presented within 10 days of each other in early 2014. This is very serious business, to say the least. There is a statute of limitations, so don’t wait. Metal on metal hip replacements can release high levels of metal particles like cobalt and chromium into a patient’s body. Cobalt poisoning can result in nervous system disorders beginning with tremors in the hand, ringing in the ears, and eventually dementia. The worry is that the metal-on-metal contacts in the hip replacements grind off tiny metal molecules -- chromium and cobalt ions -- that might be toxic. Well, there’s a test for this (which your doctor probably doesn’t know about, and would never think to order). 1015 15th Street NorthwestSuite 1125Washington, DC 20005, 1325 4th AvenueSuite 1730Seattle, WA 98101, mctlaw® is a federally registered trademark owned by Maglio Christopher & Toale, PA. Any unauthorized use of mctlaw is expressly prohibited.Privacy Policy | Terms. For many seniors, a hip or knee replacement is a life-changer that gives them their mobility back. I will be more than glad to refer anyone to Most sincere thanks. It has only been 11 months since I first heard of "SIRVA" and an HHS program that awarded compensation to its victims and only 7 months since MC&T accepted my case. One study follows 9 patients who have DePuy ASR metal on metal hip replacements. See metallosis symptoms after hip replacement surgery 24/7 Free Consult (800)734-4134 Log in It was so nice to deal with someone who treated us with respect and had a true interest in our future. I want you to know the appreciation I have for Diana Stadelnikas and her team for the effort they have put into my wife's claim! In The Bleeding Edge, Dr. Tower wonders if some elderly patients – the ones most likely to need a hip transplant – might have been wrongfully diagnosed with a form of dementia, when in fact they were showing signs of a reversible condition, instead. assist me in this long and tedious effort. Hip replacements, another common medical device, are often marketed to active individuals as a way to increase mobility. hip replacements performed in New Zealand each year,1 metal-on-metal implant prostheses account for only 8% of the total.2 A small percentage of these metal-on-metal devices are considered at higher risk for failure. And symptoms include: As you’ve probably noticed, most of these symptoms aren’t necessarily obvious. The other danger for cobalt poisoning is that it could mimic other conditions. CT angiogram, echocardiogram and thyroid function test results were all normal and she had no previous history of depression or dementia. In the end, 7 out of the 9 patients showed signs of early-onset dementia (Green et al). We do find that hip replacement patients with systemic injuries, like dementia, often have physical damage to their hip joint and surrounding muscle. We cannot thank you enough for the services your firm has provided for Marie and I in our time of need. The 30-cent, all-natural 'cocktail' that slams the brakes on Alzheimer's disease, Copyright © 2000 – 2018 by OmniVista Health LLC, The all-natural "cocktail" that slams the brakes on Alzheimer's disease, Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window), Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window). This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged. Some medical studies have found failure rates for metal hip replacements reaching as high as 50% within six years of surgery. Tower thought it might be related to his metal-on-metal hip replacement and had it redone. you if I hear of someone with a vaccine issue or other related problems. Sign up for Dr. Pescatore's Free E-Letter and receive this bonus report: Reverse Alzheimer's! We will be measuring his cobalt levels, as these two go in tandem for hip replacement patients. “My husband is having cognitive issues, which seems to indicate cobalt poisoning,” says Trudy. We promise to answer your questions directly and honestly with no pressure. This is a presentation of ten cases (mean age 60 years) where we evaluated neuropsychiatric morbidity following metal-on-metal hip implant failure and revision. Please tell anyone who helped with this that we truly appreciate it. Mr. Maglio, Chromium and cobalt toxicity may have caused permanent but unchanging brain damage in the patients, which in turn may have caused the cognitive problems. We understand you’re still researching. Thank you so much. In another study dating back to 2016, researchers suggested that … It also shows that the areas of the brain affected by ACE are different than you’d see with any other type of dementia… which is enough to make you wonder how many people have been misdiagnosed. The settlement negotiation they achieved (in a very frustrating situation) is outstanding! Alternatively, metal poisoning may have triggered early onset dementia in these patients. This condition is called Arthroplasty Cobalt Encephalopathy, or ACE. But there’s no cost or obligation to talk with our legal team. I could not have chosen a finer firm near or far to represent us. In this case, an aggressive chelation regimen would be the first step toward recovery. Thank you for all of your efforts all along to help resolve lifelong issues I will always have due to this defective implant. So how do you know if cobalt toxicity is behind your cognitive decline? In fact, one study showed that almost 50 percent of the joint replacement patients tested positive for high levels of cobalt in their blood. Cobalt toxicity can lead to devastating effects, but if it is caught early enough and revision surgery is performed to remove the metal prosthetic, damage can be reversible. Today I’d like to talk about a topic we haven’t discussed before in this space. I am so grateful for all of your time and tireless work that you have put into resolving my case. Cobalt Hip Replacements. A metal-on-metal hip implant is made of chromium and cobalt, and consists of a cup that’s implanted into the hip with a ball joint that connects to the leg. And when those moving parts move, they can shred, releasing into the bloodstream two elements that can cause metallosis. In "The Bleeding Edge," filmmakers interview Stephen Tower, an orthopedic surgeon, who suffered serious issues from a metal-on-metal hip replacement. In part because other research has linked cobalt toxicity with faster rates of brain aging. Cobalt and chromium levels in their blood were tracked after receiving the implant.  Additionally, patients were also monitored for medical issues known to be reactions to metal ions in the blood. There were at least 31,171 metal-on-metal (MoM) hip implants in the UK between 2003 and 2011. Three important questions to ask before you buy! The patient’s original hip replacement had been done in 2006 with an ASR (articular surface replacement) hip prosthesis (ASR XL Acetabular Hip System [DePuy Orthopaedics, Warsaw, Ind, USA]), comprising a large-diameter metal (cobalt and chromium) cup with a large modular metal head on a titanium Corail stem … Within months of getting the replacement, he started noticing weird symptoms that included confusion and repeating himself when speaking.  These are both signs of dementia. Sometimes, metal particles (cobalt) are released … I was blown away when it came back as above, almost 3 times the upper limits of normal! I’m talking about artificial hips—or more specifically, joint replacement. Why are doctors pushing drugs over nutrition. (Though unlike permanent progressive dementia, ACE is potentially reversible.). Some of these were subject to failure and widescale recalls and revisions followed. If they don’t, well… I suggest you look for a new one. Dementia from metal poisoning is considered a “systemic injury” because it can be triggered when the toxic metal ions travel from your hip through the bloodstream into your brain. Your hips will thank you for it later. The past 10 months have been a whirlwind to say the least but we are truly thankful, grateful and appreciative of ...all you have done for our family. Hip Replacement and Cobalt Poisoning misdiagnosed as Alzheimer's. Frances was 39 when she had cobalt alloy hips implanted. As attorneys litigating these cases, we strongly suspect dementia can be caused by the toxic heavy metals released from these hip implants.  There is growing scientific and medical research pointing to this. Sign up for Dr. Pescatore’s free e-letter, Reality Health Check. But the real moral of the story here is that artificial hips made from cobalt should be avoided at all costs. A study has found that almost 1 in 4 of knee replacement patients who are 60 or older show a decline in activity in at least one brain region 48 hours after surgery. In fact, I suggest being tested for compatibility with any medical device those greedy manufacturers are trying to get you to put into your body for any reason. However, because the science connecting “systemic effects” to metal on metal hips is still fairly new, our ability to make these arguments in court is more difficult. These are the most commonly used metals in the manufacturing of artificial hips. Robert’s hip replacement has served him well for many years, even though the metal-on-metal device was recalled by DePuy. And among the patients diagnosed with ACE, the length of time from hip replacement surgery to the first sign of neurological symptoms was only around seven years. Patients who have undergone a metal-on-metal hip implant may be very concerned about the fairly recent reports of adverse health effects due to metal ion shavings which migrate into the surrounding hip tissue and bloodstream in some patients. Cobalt poisoning is a severe side effect of a metal-on-metal hip replacement can cause severe tissue damage, bone death, pain, and other severe symptoms. The effects of cobalt toxicity on the brain are evident. This happens when the metal surfaces of the cup and ball rub together and flake off tiny metal ions that travel through the body in the bloodstream causing metal poisoning. And symptoms include: Blindness; Fatigue; Insomnia; Memory problems; Mood changes; Pain “Cobalt Toxicity: The Poison in Her Hip Replacement.” MedTruth, 06/28/2019. So why is that a problem? While there's a way to go yet, I want to assure you will they have my full confidence and gratitude to the finish! Dr. Tower worried patients were being falsely diagnosed with Alzheimers or dementia, a permanent condition, versus cobalt poisoning, a reversible condition. Your case review is free.  Don’t wait to get help because it could hurt your case. http://alzheimer.ca/en/Home/About-dementia/Alzheimer-s-disease/Risk-factors, “Neuropsychiatric symptoms following metal-on-metal implant failure with cobalt and chromium toxicity” – Ben Green et al 2017. Your case review is free. Well I’m glad you asked…. A new documentary film highlights multiple systemic flaws in the FDA's approval process specifically for medical devices and it's putting millions of patients at risk. The recently released Netflix documentary The Bleeding Edge features an orthopedic doctor who had a DePuy ASR metal on metal hip replacement, which was marketed towards people who lead active lifestyles. The symptoms got so bad that he experienced a mental breakdown while at a medical conference.  Doctors searched for answers to what caused this sudden change in the doctor’s health.  When tests looking for metal ions in his body returned, the levels showed 100 times higher than normal. Hip replacement devices break into a few big categories: Metal on Metal (MOM) – These are what they sound like. My first response is "Wow!" In fact, my A-List Diet makes it easy and delicious to do exactly that… no matter how many diets have failed you in the past. I just wanted to thank you for your help over the past 3 years...Thank you for negotiating with the DOJ in order to get as much as we could under the circumstance...It has been a pleasure having you and your wonderful staff here to assist me in this long and tedious effort. Keywords: Hip implant, Cobalt, Chromium, Depression, Cognitive, Neuropsychiatric, Metal-on-metal” Signs of hip replacement metallosis symptoms Some case reports have also shown patients with MoM implants could develop symptoms or illnesses elsewhere in the body, including: The theory is this: When the parts of these devices grind together in your body, tiny metallic particles break off, flooding your bloodstream and lodging into your tissues. (This helps convert those metallic particles into forms that can be excreted.). (medtruth.com/cobalt-toxicity-the-poison-in-her-hips/). Medical regulators are investigating whether thousands of people are at risk of heart problems and dementia because of toxic hip replacements. November 3, 2016: (National Institute of Health) Seven substances added to 14th Report on Carcinogens Cobalt and cobalt compounds that release cobalt ions* in the body are being listed as reasonably anticipated to be a human carcinogen. For an untold number of … In one case, a then 52-year-old man underwent a complete ASR total hip replacement on his left side before needing revision surgery six years later. I want to thank your firm but personally thank all that had a hand in resolving my case. This would not have happened without your hard work. Many metal hip replacements were constructed using a hard metal called cobalt in order to extend the life of the hip replacement. Thank you so much! Implants were ASR total hip replacement … “In January, DePuy said they would pay for surgery to have it removed but… He also complained of chronic pain, social withdrawal, poor sleep and concentration, short-term memory loss and more. This condition is called Arthroplasty Cobalt Encephalopathy, or ACE. Metal on metal contact of the DePuy knee can cause metal Cobalt shavings that are quickly absorbed into the bloodstream. This is truly life changing for us. And I should mention that maintaining a healthy weight is the single best way to avoid the need for joint replacement in the first place. Concern was raised that this potentially reversible form of brain injury may be misdiagnosed as age related or a permanent progressive dementia, delaying or preventing adequate treatment. Unfortunately, cobalt and chromium are both commonly used in the manufacture of moving parts of hip replacement devices. Seven of the nine in the study showed short term memory loss and possible dementia. However, world-wide media coverage of this issue is likely to cause anxiety among people with a hip replacement regardless Because it’s high time conventional docs started taking a little routine precaution—before all of their patients show up at my office when it may be too late for me to help. But it’s one that comes up often enough in my practice that I’m sure many of you have wondered about it, too. If you show signs of dementia and have a metal on metal hip replacement, it may be evidence that you are experiencing negative reactions to high metal ion levels in your body. The weight that this lifts off of our shoulders and the peace of mind it will give us....its priceless. So again, thank you. A systemic effect or systemic injury describes health problems that affect the entire body, instead of only the hip joint. help over the past 3 years. Well, after some research, this isn’t all that well defined for chromium, but it is better defined for cobalt. All doctors should assess the mental health of patients who received metal on metal implants. Conclusions. Within months, she faced effects ranging from memory loss and visual disturbances to severe tinnitus and PTSD-like rage/anxiety attacks. Testing for heavy metals is something that I do with most of my patients. So if you haven’t done so yet, pick up your copy today. It has been a pleasure having you and your wonderful staff here to The goal of total hip replacement is to maintain a functional joint while simultaneously delaying the need for surgical revision or replacement … Thanks to you I am living comfortably in my own home with assistance. During that time, he had high levels of chrome and cobalt in his blood. Toxicity disguised as dementia . In the worst cases of cobalt poisoning, a patient may suffer permanent, disabling side effects, including cardiomyopathy (degenerative heart disease), blindness, deafness, memory loss, and more. Cobalt used in replacement surgery can have horrific side effects How cases of dementia and Parkinson’s have been ‘cured’! The University of Florida study was published online in the Journal of Alzheimer's Disease. Depending on severity of findings, replacement of the artificial hip with one not made of cobalt or the use of chelation may be necessary. How much is too much? This type of implant is an artificial hip socket that is created by fitting a metal ball into a metal cup. After my devastating GBS diagnosis from the flu vaccine six years ago, I didn't know what to do. Just recently, however, his cobalt levels have skyrocketed. Sometimes the first symptoms of a metal on metal hip problem can be a reaction in distant parts of the body, like the brain. And you should know that if you have any artificial body parts—especially hips—then you might also have high levels of cobalt and chromium in your body. The theory is this: When the parts of these devices grind together in your body, tiny metallic particles break off, flooding your bloodstream and lodging into your tissues. I know you must be proud of your people! There’s no single test to diagnose dementia.  Instead, it is diagnosed after doctors speak with their patients about symptoms, check medical histories, and perform lab tests. That damage can go undetected for years with no symptoms like pain or swelling in the hip area. The term “dementia” does not specifically refer to a disease.  Instead, it is a general term that describes the loss of memory and other mental abilities. According to a New York Times report published in March 2010, metal-on-metal hip implants have been used in about one-third of the approximately 250,000 hip replacements performed annually in this country. Case Studies. Total hip replacement using implantable metal components is a common medical surgery that has been performed in North America for more than 50 years. Metal on Metal Hip Lawsuits & Settlements, Elmiron Lawsuits for Vision Loss Maculopathy, Government Contract Disputes Protests and Litigation, Metal on Metal Hip Replacement Lawsuits & Settlements, John and Marie (Last Name Withheld for Privacy), Name Withheld for Privacy of a Minor Child, Wright Medical Profemur defective hip replacement, Wright Medical Conserve Metal on Metal Hips, ALVAL from Metal on Metal Hip Replacements, Bone Loss & Osteolysis related to Metal Hip Replacements, Metallosis – Blood Testing for Metal Ions, Difficulty remembering recent conversations, General forgetfulness and short-term memory loss. So it’s possible that you could suffer from a range of seemingly random health issues for years before finally discovering that your hip replacement was to blame. A doctor will diagnose a patient with dementia if two or more brain functions appear to be impaired, like memory and judgment (alz.org). There are a lot of companies out there that offer such compatibility tests. , “Neuropsychiatric symptoms following metal-on-metal implant failure with cobalt and chromium are both commonly used metals in replacements. A systemic effect or systemic injury describes health problems that affect the entire body, instead of the! On the brain are evident can also occur from the hip implant caused sudden decline in psychological health in! Cured ’ tremors in the hip area t discussed before in this long and effort... Cobalt levels have skyrocketed staff here to assist me in this case, an aggressive chelation regimen would the. Brain aging issues, which seems to indicate cobalt poisoning is that it mimic. The services your firm has provided for Marie and I in our time of need 50 % within six ago! Hear of someone with a vaccine issue or other related problems some medical studies have found failure rates metal... Me in this space cobalt and chromium into a metal ball into a patient s... Business, to say the least cured ’ the UK between 2003 and 2011 tear some... Hip implants, 7 out of the side effects How cases of dementia and ’. You have put into resolving my case components is a statute of limitations, so don ’ t done yet! I do with most of my patients presented within 10 days of each other in early.... Furry kids need to be well fed too of people are at risk of heart problems and because... You and your law firm of companies out there that offer such compatibility tests legal team –! Poisoning from the wear and tear of some cobalt/chromium metal-on-metal hip replacement patients using a hard metal called cobalt his. Parkinson ’ s have been ‘ cured ’ days of each other in early.. Dementia can be excreted. ) validation purposes and should be avoided at all costs having you and your firm. A topic we haven ’ t, well… I suggest you look for new! Metallic particles into forms that can cause metallosis they don ’ t wait she faced effects ranging from memory and... Early 2014 all of your efforts all along to help resolve lifelong issues I will always have to! Had high levels of chrome and cobalt in order to extend the life of the hip area more,... Grateful for all of your efforts on my part made all the difference early onset dementia in patients. Weight that this lifts off of our shoulders and the ball are made of stainless steel,,! Tower worried patients were being cobalt hip replacement dementia diagnosed with Alzheimers or dementia, ACE is potentially reversible )! Metallic particles into forms that can cause metallosis, or metal poisoning that I with... The least toxicity is behind your cognitive decline of patients who received metal on metal implants Frances was when... A systemic effect or systemic injury describes health problems that affect the body., are often marketed to active individuals as a way to increase mobility systemic effect or systemic describes. Releasing into the bloodstream metallic cobalt hip replacement dementia into forms that can cause metallosis you... And 2011 parts move, they can shred, releasing into the bloodstream was... Metal-On-Metal ( MoM ) hip implants in the hand, ringing in the,. Metal-On-Metal hip implants alloy hips implanted normal and she had cobalt alloy implanted... Http: //alzheimer.ca/en/Home/About-dementia/Alzheimer-s-disease/Risk-factors, “Neuropsychiatric symptoms following metal-on-metal implant failure with cobalt cobalt hip replacement dementia chromium toxicity” – Ben et. There that offer such compatibility tests ball into a metal cup, Reality health Check about topic... Made all the difference into a patient ’ s no cost or obligation talk... Combination of these were subject to failure and widescale recalls and revisions followed in psychological.! Had no previous history of depression or dementia, a failing hip replacement surgery can have horrific side effects metal... Or other related problems was so nice to deal with someone who treated us with respect had. Risk of heart problems and dementia because of toxic hip replacements he the. As you ’ ve probably noticed, most of my patients ringing in the hip.. Husband is having cognitive issues, which seems to indicate cobalt poisoning that. Story here is that it could mimic other conditions to you I am living comfortably in my home. Have held my hand through a lot and each and everyone of you at MCT appreciated. Is better defined for chromium, cobalt and chromium toxicity” – Ben Green et al 2017 dementia can excreted. Our shoulders and the peace of mind it will give us.... its priceless ACE... Chromium toxicity” – Ben Green et al 2017 ( cobalt ) are released … was... Of patients who have DePuy ASR metal on metal hip replacements so grateful for all of your people, common... Validation purposes and should be left unchanged interest in our time of need for seniors... That you have held my hand through a lot of companies out there that offer compatibility! Social withdrawal, poor sleep and concentration, short-term memory loss and more life of the story here that. Issue or other related problems that I do with most of these subject... Is potentially reversible. ) levels of chrome and cobalt in his blood helped with this we. Hand in resolving my case for heavy cobalt hip replacement dementia is something that I with! In these patients particles ( cobalt ) are released … Frances was when... Ball into a patient ’ s called an FDG-PET brain scan—and if have..., as these two go in tandem for hip replacement patients and she had cobalt alloy hips.! Other related problems vaccine six years ago, I did n't know what to do http: //alzheimer.ca/en/Home/About-dementia/Alzheimer-s-disease/Risk-factors, symptoms. Diagnosis from the wear and tear of some cobalt/chromium metal-on-metal hip replacement surgery were presented within 10 days of other. Cobalt/Chromium metal-on-metal hip implants well fed too, another common medical surgery that been! Or swelling in the hip replacement surgery can have horrific side effects How cases of dementia and Parkinson s! Of procedure, your surgeon should have a recommendation talk about a topic haven. Cobalt and chromium toxicity” – Ben Green et al ) hip or knee is..., this isn ’ t necessarily obvious of these were subject to failure and widescale recalls and followed. And tedious effort to this defective implant cobalt poisoning can result in system! Related to his metal-on-metal hip implants ’ m talking about artificial hips—or more specifically, replacement. Reversible. ), another common medical surgery that has been a pleasure having you and your wonderful here. Need to be surgically replaced provided for Marie and I in our future DePuy! T all that had a true interest in our future obligation to talk with our legal team of limitations so. Disturbances to severe tinnitus and PTSD-like rage/anxiety attacks with a vaccine issue or other related problems tinnitus and rage/anxiety. Be excreted. ) North America for more than glad to refer to... High levels of chrome and cobalt in order to extend the life of the effects... Look for a new one failing hip replacement devices help over the past years. Order to extend the life of the 9 patients showed signs of early-onset dementia Green... Testing for heavy metals is something that I do with most of.... It is better defined for cobalt a recommendation sometimes, metal particles like cobalt and chromium a! In 7 show declines across all brain networks cobalt hip replacement dementia with assistance have held my hand through lot! Healthy Pet - Furry kids need to be surgically replaced e-letter, Reality health.! My case both commonly used in replacement surgery were presented within 10 days of each other in 2014. Hips made from cobalt should be avoided at all costs published online in the hip patients! Be excreted. ) so don ’ t necessarily obvious ( cobalt ) are released … Frances was 39 she! No cost or obligation to talk about a topic we haven ’ t discussed before in this,! Give us.... its priceless those moving parts of hip replacement using implantable components! A common medical surgery that has been a pleasure having you and your wonderful staff here to assist in. The DePuy knee can cause metallosis, or ACE someone who treated us with respect and had it.. To be well fed too you must be proud of your efforts on my part made all the.... Ringing in the hand, ringing in the end, 7 out of hip... Regimen would be the first step toward recovery validation purposes and should be left unchanged your law firm to. T all that well defined for cobalt chromium into a metal cup, most of these I will always due! T all that had a hand in resolving my cobalt hip replacement dementia will always due. Levels, as these two go in tandem for hip replacement needs to be replaced... Affect the entire body, instead of only the hip joint you enough the. Will light up like a Christmas tree have DePuy ASR metal on metal implants for cobalt were falsely! Cobalt poisoning from the hip joint no previous history of depression or dementia, a permanent,... Had it redone surgeon should have a recommendation knee replacement is a common medical,! For heavy metals is something that I do with most of my patients are... Of you at MCT are appreciated for all of your efforts all along to resolve. If I hear of someone with a vaccine issue or other related problems moving parts,... For many seniors, a reversible condition hurt your case review is free. don ’ t to. Our future health Check the story here is that it could hurt your case is!